NCAR Journal

Introduction

NCAR Director of Scholarship / Editor, NCAR Journal

Welcome to the NCAR Journal

It is with considerable pride, together with a healthy dose of humility, that we at the Nexus Center for Antisemitism Research (NCAR) introduce Volume 1, Number 1 of the NCAR Journal. I say “pride” because, as evidenced by our table of contents, while we may be in the earliest stage of what we hope will be a long and fruitful scholarly life, we have succeeded, in this issue as well as in forthcoming issues, in attracting exactly the sorts of scholars, writing just the kind of challenging essays we hoped for when we first conceived of the idea nearly a year ago. We are genuinely honored by their presence. I add “humility,” however, because if we have successfully attracted your attention already, then you are likely someone who is well aware that there is no shortage of scholarly journals that address themselves to issues related to antisemitism—many of which have sprouted up in the past few years—as well as considerable attention paid to related questions in both mainstream and social media.

What is lacking, we would argue, is a journal authored by noted scholars devoted specifically to misunderstandings about the role that discussions (and especially accusations) of antisemitism have played in confusing this crucially important discourse. Scholars, as is quite sensible, tend to respond primarily to scholarly questions driving the field’s base of knowledge (to say nothing of advancing their academic careers). And while we are grateful for the work they do, this work frequently does not touch upon the sorts of issues and questions that dominate the discourse and the myriad confusions that often arise within it. This is not at all a knock on the work itself. It’s just a fact that academic scholarship is driven by different impetuses than is the work addressed to an interested and sophisticated non-scholarly audience. (And let’s face it, it is often inscrutable to such an audience, regardless of however groundbreaking it is for the scholars who produce and consume it.)

Simultaneously, we are hardly making an even remotely controversial claim when we observe that the mainstream political discourse around issues of antisemitism is frequently polluted by arguments inspired less by evidence—let alone the unreachable holy grail of “objectivity”—than by ideology, emotion, and institutional self-interest. We are not here to name names, at least not in this introduction. But we are here to ask scholars (and a smattering of scholarly-minded journalists), whom we admire for their ability to write for a general audience while maintaining the high standards of their academic work, to help us better understand the questions and issues about which simplicity, ideology, and bad faith have sown what we all understand to be a dangerous, potentially toxic sort of confusion. In these difficult days, all sides desperately need exactly this sort of intervention if we are to begin moving, as a society, toward a more humane but also more effective response both to genuine acts of antisemitic hatred and to the weaponization of the accusation, where its only purpose is to advance alleged causes and proposed solutions whose adoption are likely to do more harm than good.

In a recent report devoted to “Tracking the Trump Administration’s Approach to Antisemitism,” the Jewish Council for Public Affairs listed among its recommendations the need to “Fight Antisemitism by Increasing Education and Understanding of American Jewish Communities and our History.” We are here to support that cause in the most expansive manner we can, illuminating not only the effects of antisemitism on American Jewish communities but all of its implications, whether for Israeli Jews, diaspora Jews outside the US, or, no less importantly, non-Jewish individuals and communities—especially the politically marginalized—whose lives are affected, directly or indirectly, by the ignorance that has historically manifested itself as what “the socialism of fools”—a term originally popularized by the 19th Century the German Social Democratic leader August Bebel—as just one form of hatred, albeit a unique one, and one that has all too often erupted in horrific violence. We hope to be allies to all such victims, Jewish or not.

Finally, we hope our readers will appreciate these efforts. We also hope our scholarly audience will be inspired by what they read here to pitch us potential contributions for future issues. We begin with no political or ideological prerequisites. We want to publish honest scholarly inquiries and interventions (and, not incidentally, to pay decidedly non-academic wages for them), and so we invite proposals for future issues from writers and thinkers who want to join us on what we hope and expect will be a rewarding journey.