From Photograph to Painting: Ruminations on the Vexed Relationship between Anti-Zionism and Antisemitism
The email I received this past spring from the Italian painter Luca del Baldo began abruptly: “I painted this picture and some friends, art historians and philosophers, expressed many doubts and perplexities, others, instead, favorable feedback. You know that there is nothing against the Judaism of Israel and there is absolutely no anti-Semite will in me.” His real concern, he continued, was with the iconoclastic violence against images as such, including Muslim and Christian examples. “I’m asking what an image is,” he concluded, “I believe that art should ask questions and truths, even not pleasant. But there is a vast debate and a complex subject. A big hug, Luca.”
Attached to the message was the image that had caused so much controversy, a precise, unaltered rendering in oils, which he titled Smashing Jesus, of a now infamous photograph showing an IDF soldier sledgehammering an inverted statue of Jesus on the cross. The photograph had been taken only a few weeks before when Israeli troops entered southern Lebanon to engage Hezbollah fighters and paused to ransack a small family shrine in the Maronite town of Debel. The photo had circulated widely onlineafter it was uploaded to social media on April 19. Trying to head off international outrage, Israel swiftly condemned both the soldier who committed the desecration and the photographer who recorded it, insisting that it had no tolerance for the abuse of other religions. Along with the handful of other IDF soldiers who had passively watched without protest, the perpetrators were promptly punished, and a new statue was presented to the village along with profuse apologies by Netanyahu and other authorities. Excuses, albeit often lame, can be offered when bombs destroy Christian churches in southern Lebanon, but there were no militiamen hiding inside the statue.
Dwarfed by the literal violence that has engulfed the Middle East, this sorry episode of its symbolic equivalent nonetheless merits serious consideration. To make full sense of it would require breaking it down into its distinct elements: IDF soldiers finding themselves in a Maronite village in southern Lebanon, their act of desecration, the photographing of the act, the dissemination of the image online where it went viral, the attempt to contain the damage by the Israeli authorities, the indignant international reactions, and finally, del Baldo’s painting and the controversy it generated. My ultimate focus will be on the last of these with the goal of proposing some lessons for understanding the entanglement between anti-Zionism and antisemitism. But let me begin by considering a few of the other salient contexts in which the prior actions can be situated, which will be relevant to our larger argument.
First, one might interpret the initial act and its proud photographic recording as expressions of the long-simmering resentment of Jews toward the suffocating ubiquity of Christian images in the dominant culture around them. As the Hebrew University historian Israel Jacob Yuval has shown, negative Jewish attitudes toward Christianity have been present since the denigration of Judaism by the Church. When the comedian Lenny Bruce joked about Jesus, “ not only did we kill him, but we’re gonna kill him again when he comes back,” he was also expressing a deep-seated Jewish hostility to false messiahs. At times, the resentment has moved beyond textual or verbal denunciations to anti-Christian actions. Much has, in fact, been made of a recent increase in the harassment of Christians by Orthodox Jews in Jerusalem, and it is telling that only a few weeks after the sledgehammering episode, another IDF soldier in Lebanon was disciplined for putting a cigarette in the mouth of a statue of the Virgin Mary. One can certainly point to the grossly asymmetrical violence, literal as well as symbolic, visited on Jews by Christians over the centuries, beginning with the burning of a synagogue in the Syrian city of Callinicum by a mob in 388 CE. But the enmity—and at times the violence—has never been entirely one-sided.
Second, the sledgehammering of the statue can be inserted in the endless story of religious, political, and sometimes even literal iconoclasm. Ever since the Second Commandment added the prohibition against “graven images” to the injunction not to have any other gods before the self-designated “jealous” one who gave the tablets to Moses on Mt. Sinai, the urge to destroy offensive images, effigies, or sculptures has roiled the waters of all the Abrahamic religions. Luca del Baldo can thus plausibly deny insinuations that he has another agenda by invoking his long-standing curiosity about the power of images and the fears they arouse. In fact, by painting an act of iconoclastic violence, he can be seen as performatively resisting the rage against images that compelled a soldier to interrupt his pursuit of Hezbollah fighters to smash an idolatrous representation of what, from his perspective, is a false god.
Invoking that likely perspective, however, complicates the straightforward portrayal of iconoclasm as rage against images tout court. For it is necessary to distinguish the smashing of graven images of one’s own deity, for example, the Reformation’s stripping the material figure of Jesus from crosses (which Catholics still revere), from destroying the holy representations of other religions, for example, the Taliban destroying the Buddhist statues in Bamiyan. The IDF soldier’s act would be in the second category, in which the two parts of the Second Commandment come together. That is, his destruction of the statue of Jesus can be seen as more than just pure iconoclasm; God’s warning against worshiping “other gods” as false idols also played a role.
A third context in which the episode might be situated is that of the actual violence perpetrated by the IDF in Lebanon and Gaza, justifiable or not as a reaction to the provocations of Hamas and Hezbollah. Here the focus shifts from Jewish/Christian relations to the conflict between Jews and Muslims. In an essay in La Repubblica on del Baldo’s painting and the reaction it generated, the Italian art historian Tomaso Montanari, while acknowledging its possible antisemitic resonances (of which more below), stressed instead the irony that the original incident it depicted had caused more distress in certain quarters than the IDF’s violence against real people: “Western governments, often self-styled ‘Christian,’ were far more outraged by this photograph,” he charged, “than by the genocide of the Palestinian people perpetrated by Israel, in which they have often and willingly been complicit in various ways.” However one feels about the charge of genocide or the likely overstatement inherent in his claim about some of the West’s governments, Montanari’s point about disproportionate responses to symbolic and real violence cannot be easily dismissed. We are often reminded in histories of the Holocaust of Heinrich Heine’s famous warning: “where they burn books, they will in the end burn human beings too.” The smashing of statues warrants a similar premonitory shudder.
These contexts for interpreting the brouhaha will seem familiar to many, but an added one that is only meaningful for the painting of the photo merits special attention. To explain it, I must back up a bit and recount how I came to know Luca del Baldo in the first place. In 2015, he contacted me with a request for a recent photograph that he might turn into an oil painting for a collection of portraits of living philosophers, art historians, and theorists who had had something to say about visual culture. The idea had been inspired by Arthur Danto, the eminent American philosopher and art critic, who had also suggested the book be called Visionary Academy of Ocular Mentality. My narcissistic curiosity piqued, I agreed without hesitation, and after several months of responding to email attachments of the work in progress, he sent me the finished painting for the cost of postage alone. Or more precisely, in exchange for a short essay in which I ruminated on the implications of having such a painted portrait of a photo, which then accompanied the results in a formidable book he published in 2020. It included some ninety-six portraits with reflections by their subjects about what it all meant, both to them personally and with reference to the fundamental issues of visual representation.
Although there was a wide range of responses, virtually all the people whose photos had become oil portraits agreed that something significant had happened in the process. “Remediation,” the refashioning or translation of a work in an old medium into a new one, is more frequently done through the application of advanced technology. In the case of painted replicas of photographs, however, the transformation goes in the opposite direction: an oil painting reproduction generates an effect of gravitas and solidity that the original photo lacks. Rather than the instantaneous record of a moment in time through a “snapshot,” it carries with it the effects of a lengthy, deliberate process in which the keen eye of an artist combines with his/her dexterous hand to create a singular object that is more than the mimetic reproduction of its model. Although it can in turn be mechanically—or better put, digitally—reproduced, it now paradoxically possesses some of the auratic power that Walter Benjamin famously attributed to original, “authentic” artworks that had inherited the nimbus of religious sacrality. Even paintings that recreate photographed images manifest the idiosyncratic touch of the artist (or at least they did before AI shuffled all the cards).
Moving from a photo to a painting also involves a transition from one cultural context into another. Although, as the art historian and critic Michael Fried has insisted, some photographers have now entered the elevated ranks of esteemed artists, who stage everything they shoot and then improve it digitally, a photo like the one taken in Debel remains on the level of a recorded contingent event.
The media themselves—painting and photography—are also a critical element in this conversation. A photograph—with some exceptions like chronophotographs—captures a singular moment in time, severed from the flow of its narrative context, while a painting can conjure up something deeper, more lasting, perhaps even more essential rather than merely ephemeral. In philosophical terms, as many observers have noted, photography is tendentially nominalist, while painting belongs more in the realm of realism, in the sense of affirming the enduring ontological truth of real universals, understood in either natural or social terms.
All of this may seem like an unnecessary argumentative detour, but it will, I hope, help us to make sense of what is otherwise a baffling aspect of the controversy over del Baldo’s Smashing Jesus, and from there suggest some new thoughts on the entanglement of anti-Zionism and antisemitism. The bafflement refers to the allegation that the painting is somehow antisemitic, while the photo can be situated in the three contexts I mentioned above, where the focus is on Jewish or Israeli actions and not the prior prejudice of their detractors. As del Baldo confessed to me in his initial email, the painting was met by many people with “doubts and perplexities,” leading him to preemptively protest that he had no prejudice against the Jewish people and that his intent was to challenge iconoclasm. My own spontaneous reaction, which I expressed in a return email, was as follows: “What is immediately conjured up in the mind of the beholder is not Jewish iconoclasm as expressed in the Second Commandment against graven images. It is instead the age-old antisemitic accusation that Jews killed Christ. I accept your protestation that this is not what you intended, but I have to say that I immediately thought of a painting I saw in Trent depicting the blood libel of Simon’s alleged murder to make matzos. The sinister power of that image is still alive, as the controversy unleashed by Giovanni Gasparro’s putting it online a few years ago shows.”
The last reference was to a notorious painting posted on Facebook by a prominent “revivalist” Catholic artist titled “The Martyrdom of St. Simon of Trent for Jewish Ritual Murder,” which depicts grinning caricatures of Jews drawing blood from a child. The painting appeared publicly in 2020, roughly a half century after the Church had removed references to the collective guilt of the Jews from the liturgy and deleted the annual day honoring the memory of Simon of Trent and other alleged victims of Jewish ritual murder in 1965. Around the same time, with the Second Vatican Council’s declaration Nostra Aetate (In Our Time), the Church rescinded its collective guilt doctrine: “True, the Jewish authorities and those who followed their lead pressed for the death of Christ; still, what happened in His passion cannot be charged against all the Jews, without distinction, then alive, nor against the Jews of today.” But as Gasparro’s defiant painting indicated, old prejudices die hard. If killing Christ can no longer be pinned on “the Jews” as a collective and eternal enemy, at least the alleged ritual murder of Simon of Trent might serve as a reminder of their insatiable blood lust.
In other words, the transition from photo to painting somehow resituates the image in the extensive archive of prior Western art, often theologically informed, which includes ominous visual anticipations of the “Smashing of Jesus.” Montanari, for example, notes in his essay on del Baldo’s canvas that “The first thing that came to mind when I saw the painting was Caravaggio’s Crucifixion of Saint Peter at the Madonna del Popolo: for that figure is tortured upside down, of course.” Although that martyrdom was in fact instigated in 64 CE by the Emperor Nero with no Jewish involvement, its evocation in the mind of an Italian art historian, like my own spontaneous recall of the image of Simon’s blood libel, is very telling. Associations with early sixteenth- and seventeenth-century paintings like Peter Paul Rubens’s Tribute Money and Albrecht Dürer’s Christ Among the Doctors, with their depictions of loathsome Jews interacting with Jesus, would also be easy to imagine. In short, a painting, unlike a photo, can unleash a cascade of cultural memories that infuses an ugly episode in the actual history of contemporary Israel, one which involved only symbolic violence, with the sedimented weight of millennia of antisemitic fantasies of its literal Jewish counterpart.
We find ourselves in a particularly fraught moment when discrete Israeli actions, like photos that become paintings, can be seamlessly integrated into long-standing narratives about “the Jews” that draw on a hodgepodge of prior prejudices. To put it in the philosophical terms invoked above, specific episodes, which can be understood in nominalist terms as contingent and random, can be transfigured into instances of an essential reality that transcends time and place. Although all prejudices are fed by such transfigurations, antisemitism has endured for such a long time and has drawn on so many different, often conflicting historical sources that it seems especially vulnerable to essentialization. That process, it has been argued, can even be traced as far back as the separation that occurred when the Church Fathers divided the biblical Hebrews into a spiritual and carnal Israel. Because Christianity was the inheritor of the former, the latter could be identified with the stubbornly unconverted Jews, who came to embody the principle of evil. It’s hard to get more essential than that.
What larger implications might we draw from this experience? Speaking speculatively, and I don’t expect to persuade all readers, I have contrasted the photographed incident with its painted duplicate in terms of the philosophical distinction between nominalism and realism, the former holding to the ontological truth only of particulars, the latter to that of universal or at least general categories. When the smashing of a statue of Jesus by a rogue IDF soldier is recorded on the iPhone of one of his buddies, it remains just an act of individual malice. Tellingly, the Israeli government quickly tried to distance itself from it, seeking to forestall the inference of any expanded significance. Montanari’s response to the painting, however, showed how quickly the image could be transformed into a condemnation of the excessive force Israel is applying in the name of self-defense. Here the expansion went from a rogue individual committing symbolic violence to a rogue state committing its real equivalent.
Then, when duplicated as an oil painting, the image became a magnet for a welter of new associations. It inadvertently entered the realm in which the ancient tropes of Jews as Christ-killers and the targets of a blood libel were revived. The remediation of the initial act from photo to painting activated the memory bank of antisemitic imagery that moves beyond Israel per se and defames “the Jews” as a whole. How inexorable the slippage from one register to the other may be is uncertain, but it was certainly potent enough for those alarmed by the increasing entanglement of anti-Zionism and antisemitism to sound the tocsin.
What made the transition possible—and this will likely be the most controversial part of my argument—is the unique role that Israel has come to play in the complicated passage from the acts of individual Jews to the holistic image of “the Jews” as such. Whether that imaginary whole has been equated with a natural kind by those—not always antisemites—who talk of race or blood or defined historically, as people of the covenant or a community of fate, it has always required metonymic representation. Absent a strong centralized institutional representative like the Catholic Church, many institutions have sought to embody the imaginary community of Jews. From the ancient Sanhedrin and medieval Kehillah to modern, more secular organizations such as the German Central-Verein deutscher Staatsbürger jüdischen Glaubens, the American Jewish Committee, or the Anti-Defamation League, organizations have arisen to speak for the whole. In addition to positive representations that have arisen from within the larger, amorphous Jewish community, there have been negative, often imaginary ones foisted on it by its enemies, a notorious example being those “Elders of Zion” whose forged “Protocols” still function as evidence of a global conspiracy for contemporary antisemites (witness article 32 of the 1988 Hamas charter).
In our time, the state of Israel, variously understood as a haven, a guardian, a vanguard of a future diasporic in-gathering, or even the realization of a biblical prophecy, became the most salient part representing the whole, the mediating link between nominalist particularism and realist generality. After 1948 and the creation of a state explicitly for “the Jewish people,” Israel became increasingly identified with “the Jews” as such. Created in the shadow of the Holocaust, many of whose survivors found refuge there, it fashioned an identity based on keeping the traumatic wound unhealed and preventing its recurrence. This process rapidly accelerated after the Six-Day War in 1967, when anxiety over the precarious existence of a haven for persecuted and displaced Jews became a triumphalist assertion of a Greater Israel dominating the region. Although over 25 percent of its population, exclusive of the occupied territories, remains non-Jewish and more Jews live in the diaspora than in Israel, the country came to serve as a concrete embodiment of “the Jews” for friends and enemies alike. The Law of Return (as amended in 1970) even if sometimes selectively applied, granted individuals with at least one maternal Jewish grandparent and their spouses the right to immigrate to Israel. The “land of Israel” is rarely described as “the homeland” of “the Israeli people,” meaning all who are its legal residents, but rather only of “the Jewish people.”
Israel is often defended as the site of an experiment to square “the people” as a demos of equal citizens with the circle of “the people” as an ethnos of a national tribe. This experiment is, however, palpably failing, as the demotic ideal of the Israeli “people” as equal citizens under the law increasingly gives way to its ethnonationalist alternative, an outcome which relegates the non-Jewish residents of the state and the majority-Palestinian territories it is aggressively colonizing to an explicit outsider status. Whether or not one adopts or applies terms such as “apartheid,” “ethnic cleansing,” “Jewish supremacy,” or “genocide,” it is hard not to acknowledge the growing inequality between the two.
What we might call, with a nod to the history of socialism, “actually existing Zionism” has had an ironic effect on the role of Israel as the metonymic representation of “the Jews” as a whole. As the balance has shifted toward an ethnonationalism within Israel and the occupied territories, its ability to represent the more diffuse and contested general community called “the Jews” has dwindled. In part a result of the growing unease among many diaspora Jews, in particular younger ones, toward the illiberal turn in internal Israeli politics as well as its callous treatment of Palestinians, it also reflects a growing fear that Israel is squandering the moral capital and empathetic goodwill acquired by “the Jews” after the Holocaust. If a metonymic part no longer functions as a positive instantiation of an idealized whole, its power to represent it begins to erode. If “actually existing Zionism” comes to seem a betrayal of the aspirations of its progenitors, its legitimacy falters. As shown by the bleak history of Leninist vanguard parties and the states they created, when it collapses entirely, the larger project struggles to survive the damage.
The relationship between Israel and “the Jews” has yet to reach that point of no return, and many who still defend Zionism as both an ideal and a concrete embodiment are trying desperately to prevent it from doing so. But the balance has clearly begun to shift. For a long time, the metonym was the beneficiary of post-Holocaust goodwill toward “the Jews” and well-earned guilt about their horrific fate, which preempted any admission that victims might turn in new circumstances into victimizers. It also benefited from the vigilance of those who sniffed behind any criticism of Zionism the odor of antisemitism, a sensitivity that, as we have seen, informed some of the negative reactions to Luca del Baldo’s Smashing Jesus. Here we might say that the arrow pointed from the whole to the part, from a more diffuse attitude toward “the Jews” to its Israeli metonym. Indeed, one of the most potent arguments for both Israel’s existence and the policies of its current government has been the danger Jews as a whole still face from eternal antisemitism.
What has changed with increasing momentum since the disproportionate Israeli reaction to October 7 is the baleful influence of the actions of the metonym on the image of the whole. Del Baldo’s painting depicts a real incident during the invasion of Lebanon, carried out by a rogue member of the IDF, not the supposed role Jews played in turning over Jesus to his executioners or killing Christian children for their blood. But it could easily become the meeting point of the two because anti-Zionist anger at what is happening now in the Middle East could arouse culturally potent memories of what allegedly happened in the past. As a result, the arrow is now pointing, at least for an increasing number of concerned observers, in the other direction. They have come to fear that not only the actions of individuals, but also the policies pursued by the metonym, the state of Israel, are tarnishing the image of “the Jews” as a whole. This is not to claim that antisemitism is caused solely by Israeli actions, let alone justified by them, but rather to recognize the sobering, painful, uncomfortable fact that they increasingly serve to trigger it.
To return to the controversy aroused by del Baldo’s Smashing Jesus, the curious effect of reawakening latent antisemitic tropes produced by a photo turned into a painting is perhaps more than the effect of remediation alone. Although the painting may have served to imbue the isolated moment caught in a photo with the pathos of temporal duration resulting in the unleashing of long-standing cultural prejudices, the incident it immortalized also aroused a more proximate indignation. The IDF soldier engaged in an invasion of a foreign country was, after all, more clearly a representative of Israel than of Jews in general, a metonym, we might say, of the metonym.
For so many years and for so many plausible reasons, the Zionist project has been the source of pride on the part of even those Jews who did not move to Israel. The cost, it has now become abundantly clear, was callous indifference to the damage done to the Palestinians who were displaced by the project’s realization. The arguments for that indifference have now become increasingly ineffective and no longer have the power to convince that they once had. Shouting louder about the alleged “self-hatred” of Jews who criticize Israel is an impotent gesture. For the sad and bitter truth is that the real fight against antisemitism, the irrational, historically overdetermined hatred of Jews as such, now requires frankly acknowledging the crisis of metonymic representation produced by the troubling state of “actually existing Zionism.” Achieving Jewish self-empowerment after millennia of subordination seemed the only way to counter antisemitic discrimination, and if somehow a chastened, genuinely democratic Israel comes to live in peace with its Palestinian equivalent, it may yet be realized. But in its current troubled incarnation, where resistance to it all too easily inspires ominous cries to “globalize the intifada,” it is hard not to pose the painful question: has Zionism begun to aggravate the very affliction it was meant to cure?