NCAR Journal

Antisemitisms: A Review Essay

Author, Nexus Center for Antisemitism Research (NCAR)

The Age of the Antisemitism Question

Even by the standards of its millennial history, antisemitism is passing through an extraordinary phase. A telling indication is the outpouring of recent scholarship that seeks to make sense of what is new today about the “longest hatred,” as Robert Wistrich famously described the phenomenon. Barely a week appears to pass without a new book on the topic. This essay will survey some of the most important works that are part of this ever-expanding popular and scholarly literature.

To be sure, we’ve experienced prior moments of heightened scholarly attention, beginning in the immediate aftermath of the Second World War, when scholars, led by alumni of the Frankfurt School, sought to apply the tools of psychology and other social sciences to understand the interlocking phenomena of racism, totalitarianism, and antisemitism. The most well-known product of that moment of scholarly efflorescence was The Authoritarian Personality (1950), crafted by a team including Theodor Adorno, that sought to identify the profile of the “potentially fascistic individual.”

At the heart of this book was the urgent question of how enlightened European society could have been transformed into a sea of Jew-hating genocidalists. Not content merely to arrive at answers about the past, Adorno and his colleagues pursued the decidedly applied path of identifying warning signs in order to prevent future recurrences.

Since that time, new works have appeared that aim to understand antisemitism, especially in response to outbreaks of it, though without the same valedictory tenor as the post-WWII spate. Frequently, they have tried to grasp the phenomenon not as a recently concluded manifestation but rather as a development unfolding in real time. And frequently, that development in need of explanation was criticism of Zionism or Israel.

For example, in 1974, Arnold Forster and Benjamin Epstein published The New Antisemitism in the midst of the intensifying debate over Israel in the international community that would culminate the next year in UN Resolution General Assembly (“Zionism is Racism”) resolution 3379.1 Thirty years later, a new wave of books appeared that announced, yet again, another round of “new antisemitism.” In taking stock of works by Jewish activists such as Phyllis Chesler, Alan Dershowitz, Abraham Foxman, and Mortimer Zuckerman, scholar Brian Klug averred in 2004 that it is Zionism that “puts the ‘new’ into new anti-Semitism.”2 In that year, the U.S. Congress passed the Global Anti-Semitism Review Act, which not only created an Office to Monitor and Combat Anti-Semitism in the State Department, but declared that “Anti-Semitism has at times taken the form of vilification of Zionism… incitement against Israel.”3 Since that time, the term “new antisemitism” has experienced a sharp ascent in public discourse, as measured by a Google ngram chart.4

Rates of reported antisemitic incidents have also spiked sharply, especially over the last ten years. The years 2015-2017, coinciding with the advent of the Trump era in U.S. politics, witnessed a significant rise in reports of antisemitism.5 Yet another spike COVID-19 pandemic, when conspiracy theories abounded asserting Jewish (and Asian) complicity spread like wildfire.6 And of course, the aftermath of October 7 has led to a rise in antisemitic expression and acts, amplified by a hyper-politicized environment that encourages ideological enemies to brandish the accusation of antisemitism against one another.

This decennial perspective reveals diverse causes and claims about the “new antisemitism,” including a heavy dose of Trump-inspired rhetorical disinhibition that encourages exaggeration and falsehood, growing economic and political strains that are classic breeding grounds for xenophobia, racism, and antisemitism, and, last but not least, Israel, which has become one of the main fault lines in U.S. politics today. It is tempting to maintain that October 7 created this new focus on Israel and its underlying Zionist ideology, but there is a longer history.

The question thus becomes again: what is new under the sun? It is not claims about the Israel-centered source of contemporary antisemitism. What is new is that the discourse of antisemitism has gained purchase and prestige in the wider political environment of the United States, including in the highest echelons of government, where elected officials compete with one another to demonstrate their vigilance in combating anti-Jewish bias. But what often seems lacking is a sincere concern for Jews as victims of antisemitism, no better evidenced than by Donald Trump himself, who both brandishes the cudgel of antisemitism as a weapon against perceived political enemies (especially universities) and regularly peddles in coarse antisemitic stereotypes himself.7

Within this political culture, Jews are not the primary protagonists; it is the discourse about antisemitism that serves an array of functions detached from the goal of defending Jews. Frequently, these functions coalesce around a conservative (often Christian), civilizational agenda in which defense of the current Israeli government is seen as a cornerstone of the triumph of the West over its putative enemies–political and religious. As part of this struggle, a significant, though not always perceptible, shift has occurred: the “Jewish Question,” as it was widely known in fin-de-siècle Europe, has become the “Antisemitism Question.” A discourse has replaced Jews as the chief object of concern.

An unlikely driver and beneficiary of the prominence of the Antisemitism Question in today’s world is the definitional scheme adopted by a small organization known as the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) in 2016. Relying on a text that was drafted more than a decade earlier and was intended as a non-binding definition, the IHRA has achieved a surprising degree of salience and legitimacy in the age of the Antisemitism Question; its definition has been endorsed by forty-seven countries, thirty-eight U.S. states, and the U.S. State Department. And why might that be? Its formulation met the moment by focusing, in its “Contemporary Examples,” on instances of antisemitism that could be driven by anti-Israel animus.8

The danger in the canonization of the IHRA definition is not that anti-Zionism can never be antisemitic; that it can has been pointed out by two competing schemes of definition, those of the Jerusalem Declaration on Antisemitism (JDA) and the Nexus Project.9 It is that the IHRA risks simplifying antisemitism in ways that are untrue to its historical growth. For if there be one explanation for the strange persistence of antisemitism, it is its remarkable malleability, its ability to assume many different, and often contradictory, forms, whereby the Jew can be at depicted once as a revolutionary socialist, a rootless cosmopolitan, a money-grubbing peddler, and an avaricious global capitalist.

And yet, this raises a challenging methodological and conceptual question: if antisemitism is so multifarious, how can a single term capture it? Conversely, if antisemitism indeed be so persistent and long-standing, does it hover above the plane of causal history and thus defy the tools of the historian’s trade?

These questions point to the inscrutable features of antisemitism that confound those who try to make sense of it. For many, antisemitism is enshrouded in a veil of mystery, as an eternal plague whose presence defies the normal tools of history and logic.10 At the other end of the spectrum are those for whom today it is quite simple, reducible to the equation of anti-Zionism and antisemitism. And in between, alternately vexed and compelled, is a cohort of scholars who have labored over the past few years to capture the current manifestations of antisemitism and the contexts out of which they developed. In the next section, I survey a selection of the works that populate the current historiographical landscape and reveal diverse strategies to understand what antisemitism is and what it isn’t.

A Scholarly Mapping

In 2008, the NYU historian David Engel issued a bold challenge to scholars in an article titled “Away from a Definition of Antisemitism.”11 Engel made the paradigmatically historicist (and of equal importance for him, semantic) point that the term “antisemitism” could not possibly capture the vast range of anti-Jewish hate, prejudice, ambivalence, and violence that swept over the map of Europe in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. If antisemitism meant all of those things, then it meant nothing. His admonition homed in on the imprecision of overly capacious terms such as antisemitism, while also resisting “eternalist” claims that antisemitism had and would always exist.

Mark Mazower’s On Antisemitism: A Word in History meets Engel’s methodological challenge. A prolific scholar of European history at Columbia University, Mazower recognizes that antisemitism, or anti-Jewish prejudice more generally, means different things in different contexts.12 And yet, there is enough in common among different meanings, principally the stigmatization of Jews, to allow for a coherent account of the overarching term.

This approach of writing “the history of antisemitism and its shifting meanings” (183) calls to mind the German historiographical practice of Begriffsgeschichte (“history of the concept,” also translated as “conceptual history”). Pioneered by historian Reinhart Koselleck, it studies the way in which concepts (e.g., state, freedom, nature) assume different meanings and are represented by different words over time.13 Mazower’s mission in On Antisemitism is a variant of this kind of work.

His book is divided into two main sections. The first reviews the formative European context for antisemitism, leading up to and continuing after the German journalist Wilhelm Marr gave birth to the term when he created the League of Antisemites in 1879. The key pre-history that Mazower traces in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries highlights the debates among European political regimes over the prospect of according Jews rights of citizenship. The prominence of what we might today call liberal democratic principles in those debates revealed what was both virtuous (inclusion) and coerced (the demand to conform) in the process of political emancipation. But significantly for Mazower’s story, the emancipatory process, which was rooted in the values of autonomy, freedom of thought, and equality, triggered an extended multi-stage reaction that gathered force over the course of the nineteenth century, culminating in a new illiberal politics that sought to exclude Jews from civic life and, by the late 1870s, answered to the name, “antisemitism.”

Given this trend, one might conclude, in line with a series of mid-twentieth century thinkers such as Salo Baron, Hannah Arendt, Max Horkheimer and Theodor Adorno, that the trajectory of modernity since the late eighteenth century did not lead toward greater enlightenment but actually descended into an abyss that ended in Auschwitz. Moreover, the persistence of anti-Jewish bias, whether one calls it antisemitism, anti-Judaism or Judeophobia, could easily incline one to an “eternalist” perspective that holds that an obsessive focus on Jews is one of the unvarying features of history. But this is not Mazower’s approach. Ever the historicist, he is intent on gauging change over time and in charting the ebbs and flows of antisemitism. Thus, he writes that the decades following the Second World War were, quoting an official of the Anti-Defamation League, a “golden age” that signaled “the virtual end of overt antisemitism.”14 It was also a time in which a keen American Jewish observer, the anti-Zionist journalist William Zukerman, asserted that Arab animosity toward Israel had “little if anything to do with traditional anti-Semitism.”15 Even Forster and Epstein, authors of the 1974 book The New Anti-Semitism, were willing to acknowledge that there was “a post-World War II honeymoon with the Jews.”

But that era, they insisted, came to an end. Mazower’s job in the second half of his book is to chronicle the important change that took place: “From the 1970s…antisemitism was coming more and more to be viewed, notably in the United States and Israel, in a frame that regarded much of the criticism of Israel as a disguised form of prejudice.” Terms such as “Zionism” and “racism” became “word weapons” in a battle played out in the sphere of global politics.16

How to make sense of this transformation? Part of the explanation was the insistence by countries from the Global South and Arab world that decolonization was incomplete without the liberation of Palestine, all the more so after the 1967 Six-Day War when Israel conquered large swaths of territory and became the overlords of hundreds of thousands (and eventually millions) of Palestinians. Set against this development was the growing “Zionization” of U.S. Jews over the latter half of the twentieth century, as they increasingly hinged their identity on reverence for the state of Israel. The result, Mazower notes, was a heightened degree of “rhetorical jousting,” but, he adds, with “real-world consequences.” Indeed, the stakes are high; since the seventies, global politics has been riven by the question of Israel-Palestine, and remains so with ever-greater ferocity today.

Is Israel-Palestine fundamentally a political question? Or is a manifestation of a deep and abiding hostility toward Jews? Mazower judiciously avoids falling too deeply into the unbridgeable chasm that divides “pro-Israel” and “pro-Palestine.” But he is also clear-headed when assessing the way in which antisemitism has come to signify different things in different contexts: “A term that began as a way to describe the hostility faced by Jews as a minority struggling for their legal rights is now used to defend a Jewish majority state depriving the minority within it of theirs.”17

A second recent book that offers up a different kind of Begriffsgeschichte, or conceptual history. Antisemitisms: A History of Jew Hating,18 Gilman, has had a storied academic career spanning more than half a century at a number of prominent U.S. universities, in the course of which he has produced a staggering quantity of books that repeatedly traverse disciplinary borders across literature, history, anthropology, art, psychoanalysis, and medicine. His new book is at once a timely contribution to the debate over antisemitism and a summation of insights drawn from prior books including Difference and Pathology, Smart Jews, The Jew’s Body, and Jewish Self-Hatred, among others.

Gilman’s strategy here can be easily divined from the book’s title, Antisemitisms. “Not antisemitism or even anti-Semitism,” he declares, “for what I study is always instrumentalized, is therefore malleable, internally inconsistent, contradictory yet seemingly coherent every time antisemitisms appear.”19 His goal, like Mazower’s, is to understand the way in which the term (and its accompanying praxis) operates in different contexts. The net effect is an inquiry into the plurality of the term, though the irony must be noted that each purveyor of an antisemitic theory tends to believe not in the malleability—or wobbliness, to use one of Gilman’s favorite adjectives—of the concept, but rather in the unchanging essentialism of Jewish difference.

Gilman approaches his subject differently than Mazower. Antisemitisms is not a chronological account of the term, since, he posits, “a coherent, cohesive, systematic history of Jew-hatred (is) impossible.”20 Gilman’s unrestrained interdisciplinarity makes the book both more and less than a conventionally cohesive history; more in the sense that it offers the added benefit of cataloguing Jewish cultural practices and norms, almost as a modern companion to the famous volume by the seventeenth-century Italian rabbi Leone de Modena, the Historia de’ riti hebraici (1638), but less in that it does not provide a fluid diachronic sweep of anti-Jewish bias or hate, opting instead for synchronic sketches that show how non-Jews have measured, diagnosed, pathologized, stigmatized, and, above all, sought to define Jews. The result is a series of historical typologies, rooted in the kind of medical, scientific, and physicalized constructions of Jews — and that are reflected in the chapters at the core of his book: “Seeing Jews,” “Healing Jews,” and “Wandering Jews.”

One of the key takeaways of Antisemitisms is the constructed nature of Jewish identity. The claim that Jews are a fixed—and inferior—race, that they must wear certain clothes in order to be seen and set apart, that they possess certain congenital physiological and mental weaknesses (or, in some cases, superpowers), that they are incapable of remaining rooted in one place—all are socially conditioned projections by non-Jews that can be internalized by Jews assume lives of their own. Part of Gilman’s task as an anthropological excavator is to peel away the layers of projection to expose the specious claims that underlie and fuel stereotypes about Jews.

A second key takeaway is that non-Jews play a large role in creating the image of the Jew that they construct for their own purposes. Gilman agrees with Jean-Paul Sartre’s oft-noted claim in sur la question juive (1946) that “antisemites invent their own Jews.”21 Non-Jewish theologians, politicians, and physicians have continually developed and promoted theories of inviolable Jewish difference. But Gilman is also critical of Sartre for ignoring the fact that Jews are co-creators of their identity; “The Jew does exist,” even if Sartre maintains that he is an invention of the antisemite.

That said, identity remains a highly unstable and contextually specific category in Gilman’s lexicon: “If identity is always fragmentary, if identity is always in flux, then why should we not assume that Jewish identity is not also?”22

Toward the end of the book, Gilman exemplifies the fluidity of Jewish identity by discussing a recent claim, made by one set of Jews against another, of alleged “self-hatred.’ The current moment is hardly the only time that this accusation has arisen, as Gilman demonstrates here and in an earlier book devoted to the subject. But the aftermath of October 7 intensified intra-group tension and enmity and has amplified the assertion, most-often made by conservatives, that left-leaning, or secular, Jews act out of self-hatred.

Gilman hastens to add that the charge of self-hatred is not exclusive to Jews. Rather, it is “a universal and complex phenomenon.”23 And this relates to a third key takeaway of the book. Undeniably, antisemitism has had an impressively long and variegated run. But there is nothing exceptional in this form of identity-based hate. Gilman insists that “antisemitisms are identical in their structure to all other forms of prejudices, the concretions in our lived experiences of xenophobia, in their potential to reshape identity.”24

There is much to be said for this claim, indeed, to understanding not only the structural similarities among different forms of identity-based hate but also the larger ecosystem in which they cohabitate. But Gilman’s own preoccupation with Jewish stereotypes and antisemitisms impels the question: might not the Jewish case be the same but more so? Why has antisemitism, singular or plural, has perdured, and in ways that seem to defy rational explication, evoking the specter of a mysterium tremendum? Gilman attempts to answer these questions by focusing on shifting discourses and stereotypes of Jews rather than on the fixed ontology of the Jewish condition. At times, the sweep and methodological diversity of his perspective come at the expense of granular contextual precision. But his synchronic and comparative approach helps us understand how we have arrived at the current moment, one in which the Antisemitism Question has dislodged the Jewish Question.

Historian Pamela Nadell offers yet another take in her Antisemitism: An American Tradition.25 As one of the country’s leading scholars of Jewish history in the United States, Nadell is eminently qualified to write a book on the path of antisemitism in this country. Similar to Mazower and Gilman, she attempts to illuminate the phenomenon without offering a fixed definition of antisemitism. Unlike them, she limits her gaze to one country but does so without the exceptionalism that so often envelops renderings of the United States and its Jewish community. What we get, in fact, is a rather stark counternarrative to the vision of America as the site of unbridled success and safety for its Jews. This is a decidedly lachrymose account that uncovers traces of antisemitism in every era of the country’s history. It should be remembered that Salo Baron, the great twentieth-century macro-historian who gave us the language of lachrymosity in his 1928 essay “Ghetto and Emancipation,” counseled against an overly dark depiction of the Jewish Middle Ages, At the same time, he saw the serious threats to Jewish well-being, ranging from liberal assimilationism to toxic illiberalism, that the modern age introduced into the Jewish world. “Emancipation,” he stated curtly, “has not brought the Golden Age.”26 Neither, argues Nadell, has the American Republic. Her story begins with the sour response of Governor Peter Stuyvesant when twenty-three Sephardic Jews sailed into the port of New Amsterdam in 1654. He urged that members of this “deceitful race…be not allowed further to infect and trouble this new colony.” Although he was overruled by the directors of the Dutch West Indies Company, his response adumbrated a tradition of hostility in Colonial America toward Jews, who were not only branded Christ-killers but also deemed uncouth and corrupt hucksters.

The book sheds important light on key chapters in the history of anti-Jewish enmity in the United States. But on my reading, it rests on a singularity of focus that flattens the texture and dynamism of American Jewish history at large. Thus, Nadell spends a couple of paragraphs discussing George Washington’s visit to the Jewish community of Newport, Rhode Island, in 1790, and his famous letter of thanks after the visit. That episode is crowded out by the experience of Rebecca Samuel, a German-born Jew who came to colonial Virginia in the late eighteenth century with high hopes, indeed, that “we have nothing to complain about” regarding Gentile anti-Judaism. But on another occasion, Samuel wrote to her mother-in-law back in Germany that “Gentiles cannot forsake their anti-Jewish prejudice.” Nadell concludes that Samuel’s “contradictory statements encapsulate the American Jewish experience.”27 But in what proportion, equally divided between anti-Jewish and pro-Jewish sentiments? And how representative is Samuel’s voice of the American Jewish experience more broadly? One would surely not want to say that it was unimportant. But the fact that it overshadows the Washington visit and letter—and opens the second chapter devoted to ”Anti-Jewish Prejudice: The Young Republic—sets up Nadell‘s thematic focus for the rest of the book. One moves from this chapter to one titled “A Misfortune to Be a Jew” to “An Uncomfortable Place for Jews to “No Age is Golden,” which challenges the view that the post-World II era offered, as noted above, “a honeymoon with the Jews.” Here Nadell makes an important historical point. Golden ages are invariably romanticized and are often the product of scholarly selectivity and exaggeration. But the converse is true as well. The depiction of an era as a “dark age” is often one-dimensional and occludes from vision an array of countervailing evidence and events—to wit, the Jewish Middle Ages.

One might respond that this is a book devoted to antisemitism in America. What should one expect? The answer is more of a sense of the ebb and flow of history, especially from a fine historian like Nadell. What then might account for the narrowed focus of this book that re-tells the history of American Jewry through the singular lens of antisemitism? Nadell tells us in the preface that October 7 was a huge catalyst, prompting thousands of conversations with Jews in which they described the grave challenge of that moment, followed by a recollection of an antisemitic act that they had experienced earlier.

I remember that terrible time well, including the feeling of loneliness as I observed friends and colleagues failing to condemn the brutal attacks on Israeli civilians perpetrated that day. But I also remember the sense of impending doom as the Israeli retaliation on Gaza began and then continued, in unrelenting fashion, for months and years. I remember the feeling of profound moral dread at Israel’s disregard for human life, and on a scale that outpaced many times over the death toll of October 7. And I remember the pro-Palestine protest movement on my campus and many others, which I largely observed rather than joined.

There were several moments at which I felt that rhetoric or artistic depictions from that movement took a turn onto antisemitic terrain. But the protests were not, in my view, disproportionate to the scale of Israel’s devastation of Gaza, nor antisemitic at their core. And herein lies a major divergence of opinion with Pamela Nadell. For her, the pro-Palestine movement that took rise after October 7 was and is unmistakably antisemitic; that date, as she notes, “marks a divide,” which I understand to be between a messy and multi-causal kind of history and a neat, linear, and lachrymose version of the past. The latter is what she presents in the final chapter, “A New Litany,” which compresses into thirty pages a long and complex story from the late 1960s to the present. The main motivating factor – antisemitism — applies universally to the SNCC (Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee) in 1968, the Durban conference in 2001, the Israel-Hamas war in 2014, the white nationalist march in Charlottesville in 2017, or campus unrest in 2024. What this approach highlights is the contrast between her account of anti-Zionism and that of the other authors reviewed here, especially Mazower, who rejects a sweeping conflationary approach. Nadell sees it differently. By the early 2000s, she argues, “this conflation of anti-Zionism and antisemitism had reached the U.S.;” she chronicles its growth into the pro-Palestine campus movement alongside increasingly virulent forms of white nationalism in “A New Litany.” This suggests an underlying, we might even say, eternalist message of continuity to which she gives voice in the concluding line of her book: “The more things have changed, the more they have stayed the same. Antisemitism remains now and for the foreseeable future an American tradition.”28

To my mind, this statement makes sense only if one accepts two key qualifications. First, one must acknowledge that it holds far more true for the experience of Jews in Europe, where antisemitism was an organizing principle of society in ways that it was not in the U.S. And second and relatedly, Nadell’s statement is more accurate when generalized to include other forms of group- or identity-based hate in the U.S. If antisemitism be an American tradition, how much more so is anti-Black racism? This observation need not require a new bout of competitive victimology. Rather, it can encourage a more relational understanding of the ecosystem of hate that scars the social and political landscape of this country, in which antisemitism is a key but not exclusive nodal point.

What’s Missing?

The three books explored here represent distinct methodological, conceptual, and geographical foci. They share a skepticism about the project of defining antisemitism in fixed form, largely in recognition of its ceaseless malleability. But they diverge significantly over the current iteration of the Antisemitism Question. Whereas Nadell believes it to be driven by a real and present danger that anti-Zionism poses to the safety of Jews, Mazower and Gilman maintain that anti-Zionism reflects a political position that is not nor need not be deemed antisemitic. The controversy about it and its relation to antisemitism has become an event in itself, but it is actually a simulacrum of the late-nineteenth-century Jewish Question.

On my reading, Mazower and Gilman address this phenomenon in considerable and convincing detail. But there are two factors contributing to the current moment that are mostly absent from their, and most recent scholarly accounts of antisemitism. In telegraphic fashion, I’d like to mention them as way of encouraging their inclusion in current discourse, as well as in future research.

The first is the role that Jews themselves play in fostering the discourse of antisemitism. Simply put, the fight against antisemitism has been a constitutive piece of Jewish identity for as long as antisemitism has been around as a term. Elsewhere I have written of the ironic function of antisemitism as a preservative force in Jewish life, by virtue of the fact that it has delineated social and cultural boundaries between which Jews may not proceed into Gentile society.29 But antisemitism has been preservative in another way. In the modern age, it has been an important way for Jews to continue to identify as Jews, particularly when matters of faith or ritual observance became less compelling. One of the most well-known examples of this mode of identification is Sigmund Freud who said this in 1926: “My culture, my attainments are German. I considered myself German intellectually, until I noticed the growth of anti-Semitic prejudice in Germany and German-Austria. Since that time, I consider myself no longer a German. I prefer to call myself a Jew.”30 Freud did what Jews in his position did and continue to do. He affirmed his Jewish identity through his membership in an organization devoted to combating antisemitism and shoring up Jews’ place in society. For him, the organization in question was the Vienna branch of Bnai Brith, where he lectured dozens of times, largely on psychoanalytic topics, beginning in 1897. Thousands of Jews around the world have followed suit and joined Jewish organizations (think in the U.S. context of the ADL and the American Jewish Committee) that pursue a similar mission of fighting antisemitism and promoting the status of Jews. Membership in such organizations has become a foundation of their self-definition as Jews. The resulting organizationalization of Jewish identity, especially notable in the absence of stronger forms of faith, practice or community that characterized Jews prior to the nineteenth century, deserves more detailed study. Especially today, in the heart of the era of the Antisemitism Question, it is important to examine how constitutive antisemitism–and the fight against it– have been of Jewish identity, as well as the extent to which a strong identitarian investment by Jews heightens public scrutiny of antisemitism.

The second factor lacking in the current public discourse regarding antisemitism is the place of Israel’s own actions. It is understandable why this topic raises alarms given the understandable hesitation to hold the putative victims, Jews, responsible for antisemitism. Admittedly, it is easy for the conspiratorially inclined to leap to misguided conclusions about exaggerated Israeli influence over world politics, as part of the classic globalist trope of antisemitism in the vein of the Protocols of the Elders of Zion.

And yet, it seems necessary to consider the prospect that Israeli action can be a driver of antisemitic action. The attack in March 2026 by a Lebanese man on a Reform temple in West Bloomfield, Michigan, leads one down this path. The man’s family members, including his brother, who was a Hezbollah commander, were killed in an Israeli aerial assault in Lebanon several days before he drove his car into the temple with murderous intent. We cannot know how deep his antisemitic inclinations were a month earlier, but a correlation between the Israeli bombing and his attack hardly seems beyond the pale. It is imperative to emphasize that making this connection does not constitute a justification for the man’s action.31 The attack on the temple was reprehensible. And yet, we can no longer avoid exploring the possibility, as my UCLA colleague Joshua Goetz and I suggested in an op-ed, that “Israeli military violence appears to have a particularly strong trigger effect on violent and criminal forms of antisemitism.”32

This is a controversial thesis to take up. It pierces the veil of the current discourse by decentering the query of whether anti-Zionism is or isn’t antisemitic. It returns the focus to the well-being of Jews. But it does so by forcing all who are committed to fighting antisemitism to recall the question that European Jewish activist Diana Pinto posed more than a decade ago (and is reprised in Mark Mazower’s book): “Are Israel’s actions truly protecting the Jewish people?”33

Testing that question openly and honestly requires us to think past the facile conflation of anti-Zionism and antisemitism that has assumed such a prominent place in the current discourse. That new thinking will challenge long-standing assumptions in ways that may cause discomfort. But it can equip us to sharpen our best practices—and develop a more responsive toolkit—to combat the varied causes of that stubborn form of hatred that continues to afflict Jews throughout the world. That new thinking can also hone our ability to discern between the thing itself and its all-too-common manipulation and mobilization for unworthy purposes.

Notes

  1. Arnold Forster and Benjamin R. Forster, The New Antisemitism (New York: McGraw Hill, 1974). The UN General Assembly resolution that declared Zionism to be “a form of racism and racial discrimination” can be found here. ↩︎
  2. Brian Klug, “The Myth of the New-Antisemitism,” The Nation, January 15, 2004, accessed at https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/myth-new-anti-semitism/. ↩︎
  3. The Act can be found at https://www.congress.gov/bill/108th-congress/senate-bill/2292. ↩︎
  4. See the significant rise since the early 2000s at https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=new+antisemitism&year_start=1800&year_end=2022&corpus=en-US&smoothing=3&case_insensitive=false. ↩︎
  5. Maggie Astor, “Anti-Semitic Incidents Surged 57 Percent in 2017, Report Finds,” February 27, 2018, accessed at https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/27/us/anti-semitism-adl-report.html. ↩︎
  6. See Daniel Estrin, “New Report Notes Rise In Coronavirus-Linked Anti-Semitic Hate Speech,” NPR, April 21, 2020, accessed at https://www.npr.org/sections/coronavirus-live-updates/2020/04/21/839748857/new-report-notes-rise-in-coronavirus-linked-anti-semitic-hate-speech. ↩︎
  7. Aaron Blake, “Trump’s Long History of Trafficking in Antisemitic Tropes,” Washington Post, October 17, 2022, accessed at https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/10/17/trump-history-antisemitic-tropes/. ↩︎
  8. At its plenary meeting in Budapest in May 2016, the IHRA developed a list of contemporary examples of antisemitism, accessible at https://holocaustremembrance.com/resources/working-definition-antisemitism. ↩︎
  9. The Jerusalem Declaration on Antisemitism can be accessed at https://jerusalemdeclaration.org/. The Nexus definition can be seen at https://nexusproject.us/nexus-resources/the-nexus-document/. ↩︎
  10. In related fashion, the author Arthur A. Cohen borrowed the German theologian Rudolf Otto’s term to describe the awe-inspiring encounter with the divine, “mysterium tremendum”—and modified it to refer to the Holocaust as the “tremendum,” an event whose scale and depravity defy rational explanation and regular language. See Cohen, The Tremendum: A Theological Interpretation of the Holocaust (New York: Crossroad Publishing Company, 1981). ↩︎
  11. David Engel, “Away from a Definition of Antisemitism: An Essay in the Semantics of Historical Description,” in Jeremy Cohen and Moshe Rosman, eds., Rethinking European Jewish History (London: Littman Library and Liverpool University Press, 2008), 30-53. ↩︎
  12. Mark Mazower, On Antisemitism: A Word in History (New York: Penquin Press, 2025). ↩︎
  13. Reinhart Koselleck, The Practice of Conceptual History: Timing History, Spacing Concepts, translated by Todd Presner, Kerstin Behnke, and Jobst Welge (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 2002). ↩︎
  14. Mazower, On Antisemitism, 128-129. ↩︎
  15. Mazower, On Antisemitism, 153. ↩︎
  16. Mazower, On Antisemitism, 201. ↩︎
  17. Mazower, On Antisemitism, 273. ↩︎
  18. Sander L. Gilman, Antisemitisms: A History of Jew Hating (London: Reaktion Books, 2026). ↩︎
  19. Gilman, Antisemitisms, 7. ↩︎
  20. Gilman, Antisemitisms,10. ↩︎
  21. Gilman, Antisemitisms, 54. ↩︎
  22. Gilman, Antisemitisms, 74. ↩︎
  23. Gilman, Antisemitisms, 258. ↩︎
  24. Gilman, Antisemitisms, 58. ↩︎
  25. Pamela Nadell, Antisemitism: An American Tradition (New York: Norton, 2025). ↩︎
  26. Salo W. Baron, “Ghetto and Emancipation: Shall We Revise the Traditional View,” The Menorah Journal, 14:6 (June 1928), 526. ↩︎
  27. Nadell, Antisemitism, 23, ↩︎
  28. Nadell, Antisemitism, 257. ↩︎
  29. See David N. Myers, Jewish History: A Very Short Introduction (New York: Oxford University Press, 2017). ↩︎
  30. This well-known statement by Freud from 1925 can be found at https://www.loc.gov/exhibits/freud/freud03a.html. ↩︎
  31. Whether this was the intent of podcast host Hasan Piker’s Twitch statement on August 20 is unclear, but it cut a little too close for comfort. Piker stated: “If Jews in America keep putting this idea out there that they’re singularly invested in Israel, eventually someone will come around and take action — not against Israel, mind you, but against American Jews.” Alexei Koseff, “El-Sayed’s Ties to Firebrand Influencer Threaten Democrats’ Path to Control Senate,” Washington Post, August 27, 2026, accessed at https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2026/08/27/democrats-odds-michigan-over-el-sayeds-ties-controversial-streamer/. On one hand, it is necessary to address the fact that some Jews call out as dangerous the conflation of Israelis and Jews while also making clear that support for Israel (and its government) is foundational to their Jewish identity. This is what we might call the conundrum of conflation which produces differential effects: for some Israel-aligned Jews, it leads to simultaneous condemnation and acceptance of the conflating of Israelis and Jews, depending on whose mouth it issues from. On the other hand, it can lead to the claim, as Piker’s statement can be read, that American Jews, at large, are not only responsible for Israeli action but legitimate targets for terror attacks by those aggrieved by Israel’s suppression of Palestinians. American Jews who have supported Israel over decades share responsibility for the long-standing denial of Palestinian rights and have an obligation to participate in acts of reparative justice. But in no moral or legal universe that I know of should they be deemed legitimate subjects of terroristic violence such as that perpetrated in Michigan in March 2026. ↩︎
  32. David N. Myers and Joshua Goetz, “Antisemitism Appears from the Left and the Right, but Not Equally,” Los Angeles Times, March 24, 2026, accessed at https://www.latimes.com/opinion/story/2026-03-24/antisemitism-left-right-political-extremists ↩︎
  33. Diana Pinto, “Israel Poses a Serious Dilemma for Europe’s Jews,” Haaretz, February 14, 2023, accessed at https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/2013-02-14/ty-article/.premium/diana-pinto-the-israel-dilemma/0000017f-f64b-d318-afff-f76b12ed0000. ↩︎