The Crisis At Columbia
Following the October 7, 2023, Hamas attacks, tensions rose quickly on Columbia University’s campus. On October 9, Columbia Students for Justice in Palestine (SJP) and Columbia Jewish Voice for Peace (JVP) published a joint open letter, saying “We stand in full solidarity with Palestinian resistance against over 75 years of Israeli settler-colonialism and apartheid…. Yesterday was an unprecedented historic moment for the Palestinians of Gaza, who tore through the wall that has been suffocating them in one of the most densely populated areas on Earth for the past 16 years….” The letter also condemned emails from the Columbia administration that expressed support for Israeli families, and denounced Columbia’s investment in Israeli companies, the dual-degree program between Columbia and Tel Aviv University, and the planned Columbia Global Center in Tel Aviv. Two days later, a former Columbia student, Malaika Friedman, was arrested (she was later charged) for assault in the second and third degrees as a hate crime, in addition to harassment and weapons possession, after a confrontation with an Israeli student in Columbia’s School of General Studies who was hanging up posters of Israeli hostages. (The charges were dropped under a May 2024 agreement with prosecutors that called for dismissal if she was not rearrested within six months.)
Then, on October 12, the first protests began, with competing pro-Israel and pro-Palestinian demonstrations. The protests were largely peaceful, but Columbia chose to close the campus to the public in anticipation of the rallies. Over the following weeks, the campus was rarely still, as Students for Justice in Palestine and Jewish Voice for Peace continued to hold demonstrations, including a walkout on October 26, jointly organized with universities across the country. At the same time, trucks with digital billboards drove around the Morningside Heights campus, displaying a screen reading, “Columbia’s Leading Antisemites” against a backdrop of names and faces of alleged members of organizations that had signed the October 9 open letter. The conservative news media watchdog Accuracy in Media took responsibility for the trucks.
On November 1, Columbia president Minouche Shafik, Barnard College president Laura Ann Rosenbury, and Teachers College president Thomas R. Bailey established a joint Task Force on Antisemitism and appointed Columbia professors Ester Fuchs, Nicholas Lemann, and David M. Schizer to lead it. On November 10, the university also suspended SJP and JVP, stating, “This decision was made after the two groups repeatedly violated University policies related to holding campus events, culminating in an unauthorized event Thursday afternoon that proceeded despite warnings and included threatening rhetoric and intimidation.”
On November 14, a coalition of 94 Columbia student groups created Columbia University Apartheid Divest (CUAD) and, in an op-ed for the Columbia Spectator, listed a series of demands of the university, including requests to immediately reinstate SJP and JVP, cancel the planned Tel Aviv Global Center, terminate the university’s dual-degree program with Tel Aviv University, and call on the U.S. government to support a ceasefire in Gaza.
Hopes that tensions might ease with the start of a new semester were dashed when, on January 19, 2024, student protesters reported being sprayed with a hazardous chemical while attending a pro-Palestinian rally at Columbia’s Low Library. Students originally identified the spray as “Skunk,” a crowd-control chemical developed in Israel and used by the Israel Defense Forces (IDF), and the Columbia administration initially banned the alleged perpetrators, who had previously served in the IDF, from campus. However, it was later confirmed that the spray was a non-toxic “fart” spray, purchased from Amazon, and in April, one of the suspended students sued, claiming, “As a result of Columbia’s flawed and biased investigation and adjudication process, Plaintiff was found responsible for disruptive behavior, harassment, and endangerment, and sanctioned to suspension from the University, forever marring his educational file with an improper finding of responsibility.” Columbia settled with the student for $395,000; the settlement, reached by late August 2024, became public in a House committee report released October 31, 2024.
In the immediate aftermath of the incident, Columbia Law School professor Katherine Franke commented on the university’s response in an interview with Democracy Now!:
Columbia has a program. It’s a graduate relationship with older students from other countries, including Israel. And it’s something that many of us were concerned about, because so many of those Israeli students, who then come to the Columbia campus, are coming right out of their military service. And they’ve been known to harass Palestinian and other students on our campus. And it’s something the university has not taken seriously in the past. But we’ve never seen anything like this. And the students were able to identify three of these exchange students, basically, from Israel, who had just come out of military service, who were spraying the pro-Palestinian students with this skunk water.
The following month, two of Franke’s colleagues filed a complaint with Columbia’s Office of Equal Opportunity and Affirmative Action (EOAA), alleging that Franke’s comments implied Israeli students were dangerous and constituted harassment of Israeli members of Columbia’s community. (An outside investigator determined in November 2024 that Franke had violated EOAA policy, and in January 2025, Franke released a statement announcing her departure from Columbia, saying, “I have come to the view that the Columbia University administration has created such a toxic and hostile environment for legitimate debate around the war in Israel and Palestine that I can no longer teach or conduct research.”)
Further aggravating the tense atmosphere, on February 12, the House Committee on Education and the Workforce informed Columbia and Barnard College in a letter that it was initiating an investigation into the university, on the grounds of “grave concerns regarding the inadequacy of Columbia’s response to antisemitism on its campus.” The letter expressed dissatisfaction that despite the groups’ suspensions, SJP and JVP continued to host demonstrations on campus, listed an extensive series of antisemitic incidents and violations of Columbia’s policy, and requested that the university provide a designated list of documents by February 26.
The next week, on February 19, Columbia issued an Interim University Policy for Safe Demonstrations, which banned protests in academic spaces, reduced the advance notice required to register a protest for approval from fifteen business days to two, designated specific times and spaces for protest (on Columbia’s South Lawn or at the Sundial, from 12 p.m. to 6 p.m. on weekdays), and prohibited the advertisement of protests before they are approved. The Task Force on Antisemitism released its first report soon after, featuring a variety of recommendations, including increasing clarity about when and where demonstrations are permitted; prohibiting demonstrations in academic buildings, libraries, dormitories, and dining halls; and making a more intentional effort to identify masked protesters who violate university policies.
Despite these proposals and the university’s amended policy, the situation continued to devolve. On the morning of April 17, 2024, in violation of university guidelines, CUAD set up a Gaza Solidarity Encampment on the South Lawn, “pledging to occupy the space until the University divests from companies with ties to Israel,” according to the student newspaper the Spectator. The encampment originally consisted of approximately 50 tents; hundreds of students turned out throughout the day to join and rally.
As the situation unfolded in New York City, President Shafik was testifying before Congress. With the House committee investigation looming, Shafik took a more assertive stance than the presidents of Harvard and Penn had several months prior, emphasizing that the university had suspended SJP and JVP and dismissed or removed from the classroom five faculty members following comments they’d made about the war. U.S. Rep. Elise Stefanik and other House Republicans appeared unconvinced.
Back in Morningside Heights, students participating in the encampment received a written warning at 7:15 p.m., notifying them that if they refused to disperse by 9:00 p.m., they would face suspension pending investigation. Shafik also said administrators had attempted to engage with students through a “number of channels” without success. Caught between Columbia’s infamous history of quelling student activism (in 1968, police violently arrested more than 700 students who were occupying five academic buildings in protest of the Vietnam War), and intense governmental and public pressure to enforce university policy, Shafik made the decision on April 18 to authorize the New York City police to clear the encampment, arresting more than 100 students. In a statement to the Columbia community, Shafik said, “The current encampment violates all of the new policies, severely disrupts campus life, and creates a harassing and intimidating environment for many of our students.” Students responded with outrage, and news of the incident made national headlines. In the following days, university students on campuses from UNC-Chapel Hill to Yale to Harvard to the University of Melbourne erected encampments in solidarity with Columbia demonstrators. While all Columbia students who were taken into custody were released by the morning of Friday, April 19, Columbia began issuing interim suspensions to involved students later that day. Despite the threat of disciplinary action, students erected tents on a nearby lawn mere hours after the arrests, and students slept on tarps on the South Lawn for several nights. By Sunday, April 21, tents had been re-erected on the South Lawn, and the administration promised a disciplinary response.
On Monday, April 22, Shafik announced that classes that day would be held virtually. However, the attempt to restore calm to campus achieved little success. That same day, the Columbia Elections Board announced the result of a symbolic referendum proposed by CUAD on March 3. Of the 40.26 percent of Columbia College students who participated, a majority voted yes on each of the three questions: whether Columbia should 1) divest financially from Israel, 2) cancel the Tel Aviv Global Center, and 3) cancel its dual-degree program with Tel Aviv University. On April 23, Columbia administrators set a midnight deadline for protesters to clear the South Lawn. The deadline was extended by 48 hours in exchange for protesters removing some of the tents, pledging to ban non-students from the encampment, and barring discriminatory language from protesters.
The situation continued to escalate on April 26 when Columbia announced that it had barred CUAD member and Columbia student Khymani James from its campus. The action followed comments James made during a January disciplinary hearing, which had been initiated after James wrote on Instagram, “Zionists in my dm wanting to meet up and fight lol. I don’t fight to injure or for there to be a ‘winner’/ ‘loser’. I fight to kill. See y’all in New York January 2024.” James livestreamed the hearing on their personal social media and was recorded making claims comparing Zionists to Nazis and white supremacists, and saying, “Zionists don’t deserve to live,” and “Be grateful that I’m not just going out and murdering Zionists.” After an additional July 2024 hearing, which resulted in James’s suspension through September 2025, James brought a discrimination lawsuit against Columbia in October 2024. The New York State Supreme Court dismissed the suit in July 2026, and in August, Columbia denied James’s request to reenroll.
As the encampment stretched into its second week, Shafik released a statement on April 29 announcing that after negotiations, the administration had not been able to reach an agreement with student organizers of the encampment. The statement maintained that Columbia would not divest from Israel but did detail a series of offers from the administration in exchange for the protesters dismantling the encampment and committing to following university policy going forward. The statement called on protesters to voluntarily disperse.
The same morning, student protesters were handed flyers informing them they had until 2 p.m. to disperse, identify themselves to university officials, and commit to complying with university policy through June 30, 2025 (or the date their degree was conferred, whichever arrived sooner), or risk interim suspension. At noon that day, members of the encampment voted to stay. As the 2 p.m. deadline came and went, Columbia announced that it had begun to suspend involved students. Incensed by news of the suspensions, protesters entered Columbia’s Hamilton Hall just after midnight Tuesday morning, April 30, and barricaded themselves inside, renaming the building “Hind’s Hall,” in memory of a 6-year-old girl killed during Israel’s war on Hamas.
In response, Columbia spokesperson Ben Chang wrote in an email that students occupying Hamilton Hall would face expulsion, and students who remained in the encampment would continue to face interim suspension. The hall remained occupied, and that Tuesday, Shafik penned a letter to the NYPD, writing, “With the utmost regret, we request the NYPD’s help to clear all individuals from Hamilton Hall and all campus encampments.” A little after 9 p.m. that evening, police entered the hall through a second-story window, reclaiming the building and arresting the occupiers; in all, police arrested 109 protesters across Columbia’s campus.
Despite the end of the encampment, Columbia canceled its commencement ceremony on May 6, opting instead for smaller school-based ceremonies. A smaller encampment was re-erected on the west side of the South Lawn on May 31 over Columbia’s alumni weekend, but protesters voluntarily dispersed as the weekend came to a close.
In mid-August, Shafik announced her resignation, and Columbia appointed Katrina Armstrong, the former chief executive of Columbia’s medical center, as interim president. In one of the first official acts of her tenure, Armstrong founded the Office of Institutional Equity (OIE), to be led by Vice Provost Laura Kirschstein, and to act “as a centralized resource for addressing all reports of discrimination and discriminatory harassment” that would “serve as a streamlined center with the express goal of ensuring that reports are handled in a fair and timely manner for all parties involved.”
Coinciding with the beginning of the 2024–25 academic year was the release of the Task Force on Antisemitism’s second report. The report recommended anti-bias and antisemitism trainings and workshops, offered proposals for speakers and panels on antisemitism, and gave a new working definition of antisemitism:
Antisemitism is prejudice, discrimination, hate, or violence directed at Jews, including Jewish Israelis. Antisemitism can manifest in a range of ways, including as ethnic slurs, epithets, and caricatures; stereotypes; antisemitic tropes and symbols; Holocaust denial; targeting Jews or Israelis for violence or celebrating violence against them; exclusion or discrimination based on Jewish identity or ancestry or real or perceived ties to Israel; and certain double standards applied to Israel.
President Armstrong responded to the report in a letter, saying she welcomed the suggestions and that they coincided well with ongoing Columbia initiatives, including “an expansion of education and training offerings and the creation of a new Office of Institutional Equity, which will help centralize, strengthen, and streamline our work to address harassment complaints, including those relating to antisemitism. They also include the establishment of the Campus Climate Collaborative, updated Guidelines to the Rules of University Conduct, and a revitalization of the Inclusive Public Safety Advisory Committee.”
The autumn semester saw no new encampments, but protests raged on, and Gaza and Israel remained ubiquitous issues at the university. Protesters kicked off the semester by picketing outside the Columbia gates, and Israel escalated its military campaign in Lebanon that September, igniting new protests. In mid-October, Columbia barred Israeli professor Shai Davidai from its campus, after he posted a series of comments on X that accused student groups of supporting terrorism, claimed a Columbia faculty member was “OK with rape, murder, torture and kidnapping,” and called longtime professor Rashid Khalidi a “spokesperson for Hamas.” Davidai had also posted videos of himself following Columbia COO Cas Holloway around on the anniversary of the October 7 attack, demanding to know how he could allow pro-Palestinian protests on that day.
On October 31, the House Committee on Education and the Workforce published the results of its nine-month investigation into Columbia and several other universities. It asserted that universities had caved to the encampments, failed to adequately discipline protesters, provided insufficient support to Jewish students, and rejected congressional oversight.
However, that report would soon be the least of Columbia’s worries. Days later, Donald Trump would emerge victorious in the 2024 presidential election, and when he retook office two months later, his administration was quick to train its sights on universities nationwide. On February 3, 2025, in response to Trump’s January 29 executive order, “Additional Measures to Combat Anti-Semitism,” which required each executive department and agency to file a report identifying actions it had taken to reduce antisemitism, the Department of Education launched a new investigation into Columbia and four other universities.
On March 3, the Department of Education, the Department of Health and Human Services, and the U.S. General Services Administration (GSA) announced that they would review Columbia’s federal contracts. Their statement read, in part:
Given Columbia’s ongoing inaction in the face of relentless harassment of Jewish students, the Federal Government’s Task Force to Combat Anti-Semitism is considering Stop Work Orders for $51.4 million in contracts between Columbia University and the Federal Government. The task force will also conduct a comprehensive review of the more than $5 billion in federal grant commitments to Columbia University to ensure the university is in compliance with federal regulations, including its civil rights responsibilities.
On March 7, the federal task force declared that the Justice Department, HHS, the Department of Education, and the GSA had canceled $400 million in federal grants and contracts to Columbia. According to the American Council on Education, the cuts affected “a wide range of academic and research initiatives at Columbia, including medical research, scientific advancements, and federally backed student and faculty programs.” To complete the weeklong barrage of attacks from the Trump administration, on March 10, Columbia, along with 59 other universities, received a letter from the Department of Education, notifying them that they could face further “enforcement actions” if they failed to meet their obligation to protect Jewish students under Title VI of the Civil Rights Act.
Three days later, the Department of Education, HHS, and GSA followed up with an additional letter outlining nine demands that Columbia would need to comply with by March 20 in order to be eligible to enter negotiations with the government and potentially restore funding. The demands included completing disciplinary proceedings against students involved in the encampments or Hamilton Hall occupation, disbanding the University Judicial Board (UJB), consolidating disciplinary procedures under the President’s Office, banning masks intended to conceal one’s identity, adopting the controversial IHRA definition of antisemitism (favored by many supporters of Israel), and developing a plan to discipline student groups that are in violation of university policies.
That day, CUAD announced in an Instagram post that the UJB had levied suspensions, expulsions, or degree revocations against 22 students involved in the occupation of Hamilton Hall a year prior. And a week later, on March 21, in a move that many interpreted as acquiescence to the Trump administration, Columbia released a four-page document detailing its plans to combat antisemitism on campus. The university’s new commitments spanned a broad range of initiatives, including moving the UJB from the faculty-run University Senate to the Office of the Provost, mandating that students wearing masks or face coverings must, if asked, present valid ID to a University Delegate or Public Safety officer, and enabling the OIE to sanction, defund, and suspend student groups involved in discriminatory conduct. It also stated that it would incorporate the definition of antisemitism recommended by the university’s Task Force on Antisemitism into school policy, appoint a new senior vice provost who would review and evaluate Columbia’s programs focused on the Middle East, hire new faculty members with joint positions in the Institute for Israel and Jewish Studies (IIJS) and the departments of Economics and Political Science and the School of International and Public Affairs (SIPA), advance Columbia’s Tel Aviv Center, and develop an accessible online K–12 curriculum on how to foster open dialogue.
Simultaneously, the Trump administration dragged Columbia further into the national spotlight with the apprehension and detention of former Columbia graduate student Mahmoud Khalil, a Palestinian lawful permanent resident of the United States. Khalil is also married to an American citizen, who was eight months pregnant at the time of his detention. During his time as a student, Khalil had been involved in CUAD and had participated in the April 2024 Gaza Solidarity Encampment, serving as a negotiator between the protesters and the Columbia administration. However, Khalil was not arrested during the demonstrations, nor was he involved with the occupation of academic buildings. Nevertheless, on March 8, 2025, plainclothes ICE agents, claiming authority under the Immigration and Nationality Act, a provision of which allows for the deportation of noncitizens who threaten “serious adverse foreign policy consequences,” entered his apartment building without a warrant and took him into custody.
Despite not being charged with any crime, Khalil was transferred to a Louisiana immigration detention center on the morning of March 10, where he remained in custody for 104 days. He was eventually released in June, by order of U.S. District Judge Michael Farbiarz of New Jersey, but that decision was vacated in January 2026 by a Third Circuit panel, which voted 2–1 that Farbiarz did not have jurisdiction over Khalil’s case. In May 2026, the full Third Circuit declined to rehear the case. The Board of Immigration Appeals had also denied his appeal in April 2026, leaving Khalil with few options in either of his two cases (his removal case, which began before an immigration judge in Louisiana and is now before the Fifth Circuit, and his habeas case, which began before a federal district judge in New Jersey). Khalil remains in the United States while final litigation proceeds. On Monday, October 19, 2026, Khalil appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court to block his deportation, the latest effort in his long legal battle to remain in the country. (He was in detention when, on April 21, 2025, his son, Deen, was born.)
As the situation with Khalil devolved, and in the face of increasing federal and public pressure, Armstrong announced on March 28 that she was stepping down from the role of president and returning to lead Columbia’s Irving Medical Center. Board of Trustees co-chair Claire Shipman, a former journalist, was named acting president, becoming the university’s third president in two years.
While the university administration negotiated how best to respond to Trump’s demands, students once again occupied an academic building in protest of Columbia’s financial ties to Israel. On May 7, 2025, approximately 100 masked protesters took over the Lawrence A. Wien Reading Room in Butler Library. Columbia public safety officers refused to let them leave until they provided identification, resulting in an afternoon-long impasse. As demonstrators refused to identify themselves into the evening, Acting President Shipman authorized the NYPD to enter and clear the building. Seventy-eight arrests were made, and days later, the university handed down interim suspensions to more than 65 students and barred 33 other individuals, including alumni and students from affiliated schools, from campus.
Columbia’s commitment to a hardline stance on violations of university policy and instances of antisemitism was reaffirmed when, on July 15, Acting President Shipman sent out a statement entitled “Our Additional Commitments to Combatting Antisemitism,” which pledged that the university would appoint Title VI and Title VII coordinators to review and respond to allegations of discrimination, initiate partnerships and implement trainings with a variety of national Jewish and interfaith groups, and refuse to recognize or meet with CUAD. The memo also made it clear that Columbia had officially adopted the IHRA definition of antisemitism. This clause was particularly inflammatory, and Rashid Khalidi cited it as the reason for canceling his anticipated fall 2025 lecture course on modern Middle East history.
A week later, on July 23, 2025, Columbia reached an agreement with the Trump administration. The settlement resolved several government investigations into Columbia and restored the vast majority of federal grants and contracts that had been canceled in March. In exchange, Columbia agreed to pay $200 million over three years to the federal government, settle an investigation brought by the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission for $21 million, codify the commitments made in the March 21 report, and establish an independent monitor to whom the university would regularly report.
In her statement announcing the resolution, Shipman wrote, “Columbia’s governance remains in our control. The federal government will not dictate what we teach, who teaches, or which students we admit.”
The new academic year brought with it a sustained, if uneasy, calm to Columbia’s campus. There have been no further occupations of academic buildings or large-scale demonstrations. In December 2025, the Task Force on Antisemitism released its fourth and final report. It concluded, “Columbia lacks full-time tenure line faculty expertise in Middle East history, politics, political economy and policy that is not explicitly anti-Zionist,” and recommended that “the University address this imbalance through the establishment of new chairs at a senior level in Middle East history, politics, political economy and policy.” Among its other recommendations, it included the suggestion that if “a class is meant to explore a particular perspective (e.g., a critique or defense of a particular theory, idea, or view), this perspective ought to be clearly disclosed in advance to students selecting their courses, especially when it has the potential to cause students to feel unwelcome, excluded, or silenced.”
These proposals were echoed in Senior Vice Provost Miguel Urquiola’s February 2026 report. His report suggested Columbia “[e]xpand coursework on the Middle East broadly defined, particularly within the social sciences, by developing offerings that complement—and are clearly differentiated from—courses offered by MESAAS (Middle East, South Asia, and African Studies), which emphasize humanistic, language-based, comparative, and transregional approaches.” The report highlighted that the Columbia Economics Department had brought in a visiting professor to teach the course Economic Policy in the Middle East, and that the Economics Department and the IIJS were advertising for a joint faculty position. It also noted that the History Department was advertising to fill the Edward Said Professorship in Modern Arab Studies and Literature, SIPA and IIJS had hired a visiting professor to teach three years’ worth of courses on the Jewish world and Middle Eastern policy, and that SIPA and IIJS would search for a professor of Israel and Jewish Studies.
In February, Columbia also announced a confidential settlement in the federal court case Students Against Antisemitism, Inc. et al. v. The Trustees of Columbia University in the City of New York et al. Columbia’s statement read, “As part of the confidential settlement, Columbia has committed to additional programming on antisemitism and scholarships for students who have worked, studied or lived in Israel.”
Today, while campus life remains relatively calm, several lawsuits are pending against Columbia. Mahmoud Khalil sued the university in September 2026, alleging that it was deliberately indifferent to harassment of pro-Palestinian students. Khalil also filed two federal suits in July 2026. The first, brought against several administration officials and several private organizations under the Ku Klux Klan Act of 1871, claims a conspiracy to suppress the pro-Palestinian movement. The second asks for $20 million in damages from the federal government for wrongful detention. A group of Palestinian students and lecturers also sued Columbia in August 2026 over allegations that the university had systematically discriminated against them following the October 7 Hamas attacks.
But whatever the success of these lawsuits, it will remain the case that the Trump administration got most of what it wanted from Columbia, and did so long ago: Columbia’s statement of March 21, 2025, which was then codified in its agreement with the federal government that July, promised a ban on masking, a review of admission procedures, clearer time-manner-place guidelines for protests, a new definition of antisemitism—nearly the whole laundry list of Trump’s demands. The more recent settlement in the Students Against Antisemitism case, while confidential, will bolster, according to Columbia itself, the school’s connections to Israel. And nothing in the dissidents’ lawsuits can undo that.