NCAR Journal

The Case for Jewish Studies in a Post-October 7 World

Author, Nexus Center for Antisemitism Research (NCAR)

Over the last several years, but culminating in the aftermath of October 7th, scholars of Jewish studies have been grappling with their place in the academic world and reflecting “how the place of Jewish Studies in today’s academy has shifted amid contemporary realities and challenges.”1

Some schools appear poised to cut Jewish studies along with other programs due to financial strains. And as the JTA reported, “The question of what happens to Jewish studies more broadly, and related disciplines such as Israel studies and Holocaust studies, has become thorny in the wake of Oct. 7 and the cascade of anti-Israel sentiment unleashed on college campuses.”2 As David Biale asked weeks after October 7th, “Could that golden age [of Jewish studies in the US] have come to an end on October 7, 2023?” Biale continues, “Endowed chairs may continue to be filled, but will they still be welcome in the major disciplines, or will they instead be forced into segregated departments of Jewish studies?” Biale and other Jewish studies scholars apparently sense “that something fundamental shifted on that Black Sabbath and its aftermath, not only in Israel but here in America.”3

The Origins of Jewish Studies

Jewish studies as a modern academic field was born in German lands out of violence that crushed hopes for Jewish equality and inclusion, following Napoleon’s fall in 1815 and the reaction against the egalitarian ideology of the French Revolution. As historian Ismar Schorsch noted, at that time, “the prospects” of political equality for Jews were “rapidly receding.”4 Then, in the summer of 1819, violent anti-Jewish attacks, known as the HEP! HEP! riots, named evidently for the exclamations of the attackers, erupted across German lands, during which the Christian attackers destroyed Jewish homes and businesses, beat and humiliated Jews by throwing them out of cafes, businesses, and public spaces. Their shouts may have been an acronym of the Latin “Hierosolyma Est Perdita! (Jerusalem is lost!), a slogan that would have reminded Jews of their status as an inferior minority in exile, and not equal citizens.

In Frankfurt, Jewish pedestrians were chased from a public promenade and post office. In Hamburg, following a vigorous debate in the press about allowing Jews access to “sites of public amusement,” from which Jews had been previously banned, including fashionable cafes, rioters physically attacked Jewish customers and pulled them out of the cafes. Dispirited, some Jews converted to Christianity, but one group of Jewish intellectuals decided to respond to this crisis by looking for ways to “unite” Jews as a people and, as they declared, to “preserve our Jewishness.” Fearing that “in the future, we, as individuals, will not be able to continue to live as Jews, or at least not in the way we would like to,” a group of seven young Jewish men in Berlin formed the “Verein für Cultur und Wissenschaft der Juden” a society devoted to academic studies of Jewish history and culture, later known as the “Wissenschaft des Judentums.” They embraced “a scientific” approach to the study of Judaism and Jewish history, and were committed to “the dissemination of clear, objective knowledge” and “purely scholarly” (reinwissenschaflische) activities.

This commitment to scientific and objective scholarship was expressed five years before the young German historian Leopold von Ranke published his Histories of the Latin and Germanic Peoples, in which he famously declared, “To history has been given the function of judging the past, of instructing men for the profit of future years. The present attempt does not aspire to such a lofty undertaking. It merely wants to show how it essentially was (wie es eigentlich gewesen).” But von Ranke did not show “just how it essentially was,” he chose to present a limited slice of history that aligned with his political views, rejecting the concept of “the unity of Europe,” because at the time parts of Europe were under Ottoman rule and von Ranke saw “the Turks” as “Asiatics.” Similarly, the Russian Empire, comprising, as von Ranke wrote, “the whole north of Asia, their situations could not be thoroughly understood without penetrating and drawing in the total Asian situation.” He also rejected the concept of “universal Christendom” because that would force him to “embrace even the Armenians” and even the concept “of a Latin Christendom,” because that would include “Slavic, Latvian, and Magyar tribes,” which had “a peculiar and special nature.” The historian explicitly identified “with the tribally related peoples of either purely Germanic or Germano-Roman origin [5germanischer oder germanisch-romanischer Abkunft], whose history is the nucleus of all recent history.” And his book touched only in passing, “where it was necessary,” on what Ranke considered “foreign” and “peripheral” peoples.

If von Ranke rejected even other Christian people who were “tribally” not to his “people,” he certainly did not think to include Jews in his history, though they may have lived in the same towns and villages as his “Germanic and Latin” peoples. The book got him a job at the University of Berlin, where he spent the next half-century. Von Ranke’s vision of the German people helped crystallize a racialized ethnic notion of the German nation and its national historical narrative. Jews were excluded from both, and this also translated into their exclusion from full civil rights, including from holding academic positions—unless they converted to Christianity, as did Eduard Gans, one of the founders of Wissenschaft des Judentums. Jewish studies remained outside modern universities for another century.

Anti-Jewish violence, exclusion, and a battle for inclusion and equal rights were thus at the forefront of the concerns of the scholars involved in Wissenschaft des Judentum. And then, just as the field of Jewish studies was maturing in the course of the nineteenth century, modern anti-Jewish hostility developed into a fully articulated political movement that came to be known as antisemitism, whose explicit goal was to curtail Jews’ rights as citizens and stem their social climb. Antisemitism and Jewish studies were and would remain connected.

A Field Within Other Fields

In these early decades of modern universities, Jewish studies had no place outside of theology departments, whose faculty engaged what Lawrence Schiffman called “academic supersessionism,” the study of Jews and Judaism to illuminate the history of Christianity. In light of this exclusion, Jews established their own institutions—mostly modern rabbinic seminaries and community-focused entities such as the YIVO Institute, in which autonomous scholarship about Jews was pursued.

But studying Jews and their history and culture for its own value in non-Jewish institutions would have to wait until Harry Austryn Wolfson, whom Commentary magazine called “a founding father of Jewish studies in America,” was appointed an instructor of Jewish philosophy at Harvard in 1915 and Salo Baron became the Nathan Miller Professor of Modern Jewish History at Columbia in 1930. Both Baron and Wolfson belonged to what the sociologist Lewis S. Feuer called “that first generation of East European Jews who won acceptance as university teachers in the United States.”

The Wolfson case highlights some difficulties Jewish studies faced in American universities, which arguably reverberate today. When he was first appointed an instructor of Jewish philosophy at Harvard in 1915, his appointment was unlike others at the university—he had to secure external funding for his own salary. The appointment was on an annual contract, conditional on the funding. In 1921, he was promoted to assistant professor, but four years later, at his reappointment, he was told that the contract would end unless there was permanent funding for his position. The position was ultimately endowed by Lucius Littauer, a Harvard graduate, former congressman, and wealthy businessman, in memory of his father, Nathan. This is how the Nathan Littauer Professor of Hebrew Literature at Harvard was created. But being a Jewish professor at Harvard was isolating, let alone a Jewish professor of Jewish studies. Wolfson did what he could to avoid a perception of association with Jewish institutions or causes. For instance, he did not raise any objections to Harvard’s continuous restrictions on the number of Jews it admitted, even as the Hitler and his henchmen made life increasingly impossible for Jewish scholars and students across much of Europe.6

Then, in 1928, a young widow in New York, Linda Rosenberg Miller, endowed the Nathan J. Miller Professor of Jewish History, Literature, and Institutions at Columbia University, to honor the memory of her husband, who had died in Paris a year earlier. Though named for her husband, the Miller chair was Linda R. Miller’s legacy.

It took quite a while, and a few tries to fill the position. Finally, in January 1930, Columbia announced the appointment to the Nathan J. Miller Chair of the young Salo Baron, who since 1925 had served as the head of the Department of Jewish History at the Jewish Institute of Religion. Baron’s appointment changed the trajectory of Jewish studies in the United States and beyond.

Both Baron and Wolfson—perhaps because of their position as Jewish studies scholars in non-Jewish institutions—located the studies of Jews and Jewish history and culture in the larger context. Wolfson, whom The New York Times called “philosopher and one of the world’s leading scholars on comparative religion,” put Jewish philosophy in conversation with Greek, Christian, and Islamic philosophies. Baron wrote about Jewish history as integrated into what he called “general history,” that is, the history of the majority societies where Jews lived. Indeed, in one of his later essays, written after he had spent decades at Columbia, Baron pleaded with scholars “to balance […] external and internal pressures against one another and thus to promote the deeper understanding of the entire Jewish past.” He hoped that this new approach would shed light not only on Jewish history but “on general history as well,” which would be “viewed not from the traditional angle of the majority peoples but rather from the vantage point of a permanent minority.” In effect, Baron argued that studying Jews, as “a permanent minority,” would reveal something new also about the history of the majority. In this vision, studying Jews would offer a new lens onto majority societies and on the Jewish experience as well.

For many—both Jews and non-Jews—Jewish studies remained an identity studies field. One estimate finds that between 1911 and 1913, the number of Jewish students at many American universities could be counted in dozens: “21 Jewish students at the University of Colorado, 62 at Ohio State, 400 at Cornell, 50 to 60 at Pennsylvania State, 160 at Harvard, 50 at Rutgers, 100 at Minnesota, 75 at Missouri, 325 at Pennsylvania, and 70 at Wisconsin.”7 In the first census of Jewish students, conducted in 1935, were 105,000 Jewish students, constituting 9.3 per cent of a total college population of 1,148,000, according to estimates based on the data.8 Most of these Jewish students attended colleges in New York City, most often the publicly funded “City College.” By the time of the first comprehensive study of Jewish students at 850 colleges and universities in the United States, conducted in 1963, absolute number of Jewish students increased to about 275,000, accounting to about 80% of the college-age Jewish population, but their proportionate number dropped to just over six percent of the total college student population of 4,420,000.9 If Jews were overrepresented in colleges, they nonetheless remained a small minority of the overall student population. And with Jews constituting an even smaller minority globally—about 15 million out of nearly 8 billion, 10 or 0.2%, or to put it differently, the total Jewish population in the world is a little less than the population of Buenos Aires—it might be a reasonable question to ask: why should Jewish studies have any, let alone a prominent place in the academy and at universities? This question has certainly resonated since October 7th.

Impact on Theological and Legal Frameworks

Jewish studies is important not because of raw population numbers of Jews, but because of the role Jews or the figure of “the Jews” have played in the Western world—the world shaped by the Hebrew and Christian scriptures, including Islam. In the New Testament, the word Jew/Jews/Israel appears over 200 times, not to mention Pharisees, priests, and scribes. In the Qur’an, Jews/Jewry and “Children of Israel” are mentioned, by my rough count, some 65 times (Children of Israel 43 times, and Jews/Jewry 22 times) directly, and excluding the broader “People of the Book,” which also encompasses Christians. So, Jews, or, rather, the idea of Jews, become very central to billions of people professing Christianity or Islam. These religious texts have given rise to tropes and hermeneutical ideas of Jews, which have shaped the cultures and laws of those societies that profess these texts to be holy scriptures. In turn, they have left an impact on real Jews. And studying Jews matters because they are so central to the worldview of billions of people, and, thus, it is important to study and understand not only the idea of Jews but also Jews themselves. Not doing so would be akin to either ignoring, for example, the centrality of Black experience in the US, or, worse, accepting the dominant white American version of that history.

It is impossible to study and understand the Western world, and geopolitics today, without understanding how the mere presence of Jews as a small minority shaped the legal system and broader cultural frameworks. Since the rise and expansion of Christianity as a universal religion, Jews have played a central role in Western—Christian and Islamic— imagination. Not because Jews insisted on their centrality, not because Jews had the power to do so, but rather because they came to be perceived as central to the dominant societies, especially their theologies, and social and religious hierarchies.

What began as a dispute over theology and identity between the nascent Christian sect and Jews who rejected the Jesus movement ended up shaping not only theology and Christian identity but also law, within Christendom, Islam, and, then later, also racial laws in European colonies. Once these theological values were embedded in law, they created social and political hierarchies and legislated Jews’ inferior social status. These laws provided a framework for dealing with minorities considered inferior. In Roman Christian law, intermarriage between Jews and Christians was prohibited, Jews’ ownership of Christian slaves, Jews were banned from public office and any honors, from being in any position of authority over Christians, and from serving as witnesses against Christians. To ensure their permanent minority status, they were prohibited from building new synagogues and restoring old ones. This legal framework survived for nearly a millennium and a half, until it was overturned in the aftermath of the French Revolution.

Roman law influenced Islamic laws regulating the status of ahl al-dhimma, literally “people of the pact” — that is legally sanctioned non-Muslims, that established a social and religious hierarchy for Jews and Christians (later also other non-Muslims) that lasted over 1200 years. The dhimmi, protected non-Muslims, were permitted to live among Muslims in an inferior position and practice their religion with restrictions—like Jews under Christendom. They had to pay special taxes (jizya, a poll-tax and haraj, a land tax) and were prohibited from carrying arms and riding horses. They were banned from holding public processions and converting others to their religion. Like Jews in Roman Christian law, the dhimmi were not allowed to build new houses of worship or repair old ones. Their homes could not be higher and nicer than the homes of Muslims. The dhimmi were also required to wear distinct clothes—a policy that would influence the creation of the Jewish badge in Christian Europe and negotiations between European powers and Islamic governments regarding Christian visitors to their lands.

The significance of the dhimmi system is often underappreciated in the Western analyses of the conflicts in the Middle East, which looks at the Middle East from the perspective of European dominance. But from the Islamic perspective, European, thus Christian, history of colonial control and the rise of a Jewish state disrupted power dynamic and social hierarchies of over a millennium.

This Roman and Christian legacy became a foundation for the Western legal system. Laws that applied to Jews in ancient and medieval Christendom later shaped also the legal system in the colonies. For example, the medieval concept of “perpetual servitude” of Jews was applied to justify European colonial expansion and enslavement of Africans, and the concept of purity of blood and the notion of hereditary transfer of status created a legal framework, which, in the Americas, became, by legal design, hereditary—indeed perpetual—enslavement. Similarly, Virginia’s law passed in 1705, “An Act concerning Servants and Slaves,” for example, echoed laws restricting Jews’ ownership of Christian slaves from the Christian Roman Empire.

Jewish History is the History of the Modern World

In modern times, ideas about citizenship and nationhood were shaped in Europe by a debate about Jews, in a similar way that racial hierarchy shaped concepts of citizenship in the United States. It is enough to compare the debates about Jews in Europe with statements about the citizen status of Black Americans found in the congressional debates regarding the admission of Missouri into the Union in 1820 and then in the Dred Scott case. When the question of citizenship was first raised in Europe after the French Revolution, Jews were seen as incompatible with equal citizenship. In 1790, Anne-Louis-Henri de La Fare, the bishop of Nancy and a deputy to the French Parlement, argued that “Wisdom gives the legislative body the imperative law not to grant to the Jews, whom it must always consider as foreigners among us, the quality and the rights of French citizens, and active citizens.11 Six years later, the Dutch legislators facing the same question of admission of Jews as equals. One of the deputies, Ysbrand van Hamelsveld, argued that “Collectively speaking Jews cannot share in our [Dutch] social rights as citizens as long as they are Jews.” And in 1848, the German writer Bruno Bauer claimed that “The idea of human rights was discovered for the Christian world in the last century only. It is not innate in man.” It did not apply to Jews. In the US, the concept of citizenship was not defined until the nineteenth century. In 1820, the Speaker of the House, Philip Barbour of Virginia, asserted, “the Constitution of the US was framed by the States respectively, consisting of the European descendants of white men…. We, the white people…formed a Constitution.” In the Dred Scott case in 1856, Chief Justice Taney asked, “can a negro whose ancestors were imported into this country and sold as slaves become a member of the political community formed and brought into existence by the Constitution of the United States, and as such become entitled to all the rights, and privileges, and immunities, guaranteed by that instrument to the citizen, one of which rights is the privilege of suing in a court of the United States in the cases specified in the Constitution?” Taney argued that the concept of “citizens” was synonymous, pertaining to “the political body” and including those who held “the power and conduct the Government through their representatives.” Black people, he claimed, were not “included, and were not intended to be included, under the word ‘citizens’ in the Constitution, and can therefore claim none of the rights and privileges which that instrument provides for and secures to citizens of the United States.”

Power dynamics in relation to Jews is crucial in understanding the history of the 20th century. Can one fully comprehend this history without considering the exclusionary violence against Jews in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century, the pogroms and the refugee crisis in the aftermath of WWI, the antisemitic fantasies about Jews that animated Hitler and pushed Europe and the world into a war in which more than 60 million people were killed, among them the millions of Jews? Likewise, taking account for the power dynamic and the place Jews (and Christians) had as minority dhimmis within Islam for over a millennium is critical in understanding the current conflict in the Middle East. In 1917, Musa Kazim Husseini, the mayor of Jerusalem, stated that “We Arabs, Muslim and Christian, always sympathized profoundly with the persecuted Jews and their misfortunes in other countries but there is a wide difference between this sympathy and the acceptance of such a nation…ruling over us.”

During the debates over the status of Palestine in the aftermath of World War I, many Catholic leaders objected to the creation of a Jewish state and to this effective acquisition of political power by Jews. In 1919, for example, Cardinal Gasparri to Pierre van Zuylen, the secretary at the Belgian embassy to the Holy See noted, “The danger we fear most is the establishment of a Jewish state in Palestine. We would have found nothing wrong in Jews entering that country and setting up agricultural colonies. But that they be given the rule over the Holy Places is intolerable for Christians.” A year later, a new French Catholic journal Documentation Catholique reiterated this sentiment, “most shameful for Christianity will be to see the Holy Places occupied by the Jews, and perhaps even under their political yoke.” Modern opponents of the existence of the state wittingly or unwittingly echo some of these sentiments. In 2014, Mahmood Mamdani argued that “The Palestinian challenge is to persuade the Jewish population and the world, just as in South Africa, the longtime security of a Jewish homeland in historic Palestine requires the dismantling of the Jewish state…. The lesson for Palestine and Israel is that historic Palestine can be a homeland for Jews but not for Jews only. Jews can have a homeland in historic Palestine. But not a state.” While the actions of the State of Israel and its exercise or abuse of power over its Arab minority and Palestinians in occupied territories are unarguably important factors in current anti-Israel attitudes, the explicit opposition to the state’s existence cannot be understood without also taking account of the historical power structures and theology.

Academic disciplines and fields of study are built on disciplinary epistemic traditions. National histories or periods are shaped by narratives of dominant societies. Jews, a minority everywhere for millennia, were not included; their history was sequestered to “Jewish history.” But by ignoring Jews and how they were treated and conceptualized, we are missing and, perhaps, misunderstanding significant aspects of history. The Reformation will look different, and so will the history of race and racism, when we understand that some of the European racialization of other peoples comes through religion together with the perception and localization of Jews and Judaism in the Middle East. Postcolonial studies, while focusing on the study of Western power, dominance, and its cultural entrenchment, often misunderstand the role that Jews, as a dominated minority, were forced to play in that ethos of Western power and dominance. Inclusion of Jews and a consideration of continuities might also help reconsider questions of Islamic empires and their legacy. And even the binary discourse of oppressors and oppressed, shaped by post-World War II political context, including in Israel/Palestine, might be different if a wider lens that includes a discussion of Jews and their place in global history and social and political hierarchies before 1948, might become less reductive, as simplistic binaries tend to be.

As these examples suggest, Jewish studies may help us understand broader issues in history and be part of university curricula despite Jewish demographics. But what about studying Jews themselves? Given the importance of Jews for the dominant societies, it is important to study Jewish lived experiences and their culture as well, to avoid distortions that come from studying a minority group through the lens of the dominant majority. This should not be a radical proposition. Anyone who has studied Black history in the United States or subaltern groups in colonial empires understands the importance of retrieving the voices of subjugated communities. Indeed, just as postcolonial studies have effectively challenged the colonial powers’ perception of local populations as inferior and examined not only the lasting effects of colonial rule but also helped us understand how subaltern groups understood themselves, Jewish studies provides precisely such a counterweight to the caricatured perceptions of Jews that have been deeply embedded in the imaginations of dominant societies. Jewish studies also provides an opportunity to study a subjugated minority, which was also able to produce a large amount of writing and historical evidence on its own. Much is lost, for sure, but much has been preserved.

So, the field of Jewish studies within the academy is important not because Jewish donors demand so—though their voices have been lately amplified and increasingly demand influence on scholarship and teaching. Yet, despite their sometimes intolerable political demands, the fact is that Jewish donors exist precisely because the academic world has often refused, from the earliest decades, to include Jewish studies. And yet, Jewish studies scholarship is important precisely because Jews played—not of their own choosing—such a central, if unacknowledged, role in the dominant societies’ histories. And while the small total number of Jews, historically and now, might raise questions as to why an area of scholarship specifically devoted to them should have a place within the academic world, Jewish studies is not some insidious propaganda to humanize Jews at expense of others, undeserved to be included in the academic world. Jewish studies is a field that helps illuminate the histories of many societies and civilizations. Its exclusion or marginalization leaves those histories incomplete.

Notes

  1. Laura Leibman, “From the President,” AJS Perspectives, Winter 2025, 21. ↩
  2. https://www.jta.org/2025/09/03/united-states/jewish-studies-faculty-at-u-of-oregon-rally-to-protect-their-jobs-from-feared-budget-cuts; https://dailyorange.com/2025/10/letter-to-the-editor-paused-majors-bear-burden-of-unsolved-systemic-issues/ ↩
  3. David Biale essay [full citation forthcoming] ↩
  4. Ismar Schorsch, Leopold Zunz: Creativity in Adversity (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2017), 29–30. ↩
  5. [Citation forthcoming] ↩
  6. Lewis S. Feuer, “Recollections of Harry Austryn Wolfson,” American Jewish Archives 28, no. 1 (April 1976): 33. ↩
  7. [Citation forthcoming] ↩
  8. [Citation forthcoming] ↩
  9. [Citation forthcoming] ↩
  10. [Citation forthcoming] ↩
  11. Anne-Louis-Henri de La Fare, Opinion de M. L’évêque de Nancy, Député de Lorraine, sur L’admissibilité des Juifs à la Plénitude de L’état-Civil, Et des Droits de Citoyens Actifs (Paris: Librarie au Palace Marchand, 1790), 10. ↩